Pappardelle's Pizzeria & Restaurant, italian restaurant in Bethpage, Oyster Bay

Eat & drink

Oldest restaurants in and near Oyster Bay, 2026

The Oyster Bay area’s longest-running restaurants: 10 local places, Oyster Bay first, then neighboring towns, each oldest first, by the year each one says it opened. 2 are in Oyster Bay and 8 are in neighboring Freeport, Mineola and Baldwin and nearby towns, within 10 miles.

Updated November 2026 · 10 independent places in and near Oyster Bay · facts from each business’s own website

The list

Oldest restaurants in and near Oyster Bay

10 places in and near Oyster Bay.

  1. Pappardelle's Pizzeria & Restaurant

    Bethpage

    Open since 1986 (40 years)

    Pappardelle’s Pizzeria & Restaurants is a locally owned and operated Italian restaurant that has been serving Bethpage since 1986. per their website (pappardelles.com), checked November 2026

    Mon–Sat 11 AM–10 PM · Sun 12 PM–10 PM

    554 Stewart Ave, Bethpage, NY 11714

  2. Cafe Testarossa

    Syosset

    Open since 1988 (38 years)

    per their website (cafetestarossa.com), checked November 2026

    Wed, Thu 4 PM–9:30 PM · Fri, Sat 4 PM–10 PM · Sun 4 PM–9 PM · closed Mon, Tue

    499 Jericho Tpke, Syosset, NY 11791

  3. Bracco's Clam & Oyster Bar

    Freeport, 10 mi

    Open since 1929 (97 years)

    Bracco's Clam & Oyster Bar Est. 1929 per their website (braccosny.com), checked November 2026

    Mon–Thu 11:30 AM–midnight · Fri, Sat 11:30 AM–1:30 AM · Sun 11:30 AM–midnight

    319 Woodcleft Ave, Freeport, NY 11520

  4. Otto's Sea Grill

    Freeport, 10 mi

    Open since 1929 (97 years)

    Open since 1929 per their website (ottosseagrillny.com), checked November 2026

    271 Woodcleft Ave, Freeport, NY 11520

  5. Kucks Delicatessen

    Mineola, 8 mi

    Open since 1936 (90 years)

    Established in 1936, Kuck's Deli has been serving the Long Island community for 85 years. per their website (kuck-s-deli.webnode.page), checked November 2026

    141 Mineola Blvd Unit A, Mineola, NY 11501

  6. Novi

    Baldwin, 9 mi

    Open since 1937 (89 years)

    Serving Baldwin & Long Island with love since 1937 per their website (novibaldwin.com), checked November 2026

    Mon–Thu 12 PM–9:30 PM · Fri, Sat 12 PM–10:30 PM · Sun 12 PM–9 PM

    99 Merrick Rd, Baldwin, NY 11510

  7. Piccola Bussola Ristorante

    West Hills, 5 mi

    Open since 1957 (69 years)

    A FAMILY TRADITION SINCE 1957 per their website (piccolabussolarestaurant.com), checked November 2026

    970 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington, NY 11743

  8. Bagel Plaza

    Merrick, 8 mi

    Open since 1962 (64 years)

    Bagels, bialys, smoked fish, homemade salads and catering - baked on premises daily since 1962. per their website (bagelplaza.com), checked November 2026

    daily 6 AM–2 PM

    1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick, NY 11566

  9. Chicken Delight

    Westbury, 5 mi

    Open since 1965 (61 years)

    Family run and operated since 1965. per their website (chickendelightny.com), checked November 2026

    Mon–Thu 10:30 AM–10 PM · Fri, Sat 10:30 AM–11 PM · Sun 10:30 AM–10 PM

    476 Maple Ave, Westbury, NY 11590

  10. Lareira Restaurant

    Mineola, 7 mi

    Open since 1982 (44 years)

    Established in 1982 & proud to be the oldest Portuguese restaurant on Long Island per their website (wwww.lareirarestaurant.com), checked November 2026

    Tue–Thu 11:30 AM–9 PM · Fri, Sat 11:30 AM–10 PM · Sun 11:30 AM–9 PM · closed Mon

    66 E Jericho Tpke, Mineola, NY 11501

Map

Where they are in and near Oyster Bay

Map of 10 places loads as you scroll.

How we checked

A place is listed when its own website states the year it opened ("since 1952", "established 1948") or Wikidata records its founding year; if the two disagree it is left out. Shown: places open 50 years or more, or the ten oldest found that have been open 25 years or more, oldest first, with Oyster Bay places before those in neighboring towns.

Each entry is a fact the business states on its own website. We fetched the homepage of every listed Oyster Bay and neighboring-town restaurant and bar that links its own site, plus up to three pages on the same site (menu, specials, events or about), and kept only explicit statements, quoted with a link to the page they came from.

Checked November 2026. A claim more than 12 months old is dropped. Menus, specials and event nights change, so confirm with the business before you go.

Only independent local businesses are included, with no chains: places in Oyster Bay first, then places in a neighboring town within 10 miles of the Oyster Bay center and not across water, each marked with its town and distance and linked to its listing on that town’s Local City Network site. A business whose website does not state the fact is not listed here, which does not mean it lacks it.

Sites that block automated visits, or ask robots not to visit, were skipped rather than worked around.

Questions

Oldest restaurants in and near Oyster Bay: answers

What is the oldest restaurant in and near Oyster Bay?

By the year it states, Bracco's Clam & Oyster Bar (Freeport): open since 1929 (97 years). This counts only restaurants in this guide’s directory that state a year.

Which Oyster Bay-area restaurants have been open 50 years or more?

7: Bracco's Clam & Oyster Bar, Otto's Sea Grill, Kucks Delicatessen, Novi and 3 more.

Which are the five oldest?

Bracco's Clam & Oyster Bar (1929), Otto's Sea Grill (1929), Kucks Delicatessen (1936), Novi (1937) and Piccola Bussola Ristorante (1957).

Is the opening year the same business at the same address?

Not always. The year is the one each business gives, which can include earlier locations or owners.

How is this list made?

A place is listed when its own website states the year it opened ("since 1952", "established 1948") or Wikidata records its founding year; if the two disagree it is left out. Shown: places open 50 years or more, or the ten oldest found that have been open 25 years or more, oldest first, with Oyster Bay places before those in neighboring towns. 2 are in Oyster Bay and 8 are in neighboring Freeport, Mineola and Baldwin and nearby towns, within 10 miles. Checked November 2026.

Oyster Bay AI

Your Oyster Bay local guide
Hey there!

I'm Oyster Bay AI. Ask about neighborhood food, independent shops, local history or planning a visit.

AI recommendations may be inaccurate. Verify hours and prices. Questions are processed by Cloudflare. Privacy