Eat & drink
Desserts in and near Oyster Bay, 2026
Dessert in and near Oyster Bay: 5 local places across 2 kinds: bakeries and dessert shops. All 5 are in neighboring West Hempstead, Baldwin and Melville and nearby towns, within 10 miles.
Updated October 2026 · 5 independent places in and near Oyster Bay
Bakeries & pastry shops
4 places in and near Oyster Bay.
Sydney's Sweets
Open until 6 PM Thu–Sat
Good to know: Price level $$ (moderate).
Thu–Sat 12 PM–6 PM · Sun 11 AM–2 PM · closed Mon–Wed
Vienna Cookie Company
Open until 5 PM Sat
Good to know: Closed Sundays and Mondays.
Tue–Fri 11 AM–4 PM · Sat 11 AM–5 PM · closed Mon, Sun
Banana Bread Co
Good to know: Rob Brigati is the managing partner of Banana Bread Co.
daily 9 AM–5 PM
Catalina's Bake Shop
Open until 6 PM Tue–Sat
Good to know: Closed Mondays.
Tue–Sat 9 AM–6 PM · Sun 9 AM–2 PM · closed Mon
Dessert shops & sweets
1 place in and near Oyster Bay.
Emile's Candies
Open until 6 PM Tue–Fri
Good to know: Closed Sundays and Mondays. The store has been family-owned and operated over the years, with current owners Jackie and Michael Brown purchasing the business in 2017.
Tue–Fri 10 AM–6 PM · Sat 10 AM–5 PM · closed Mon, Sun
Where they are in and near Oyster Bay
Map of 5 places loads as you scroll.
How this list is made
A place is listed when its kind is an ice cream, gelato or frozen yogurt shop, a bakery or pastry shop, a donut shop, a boba or bubble tea shop, or a dessert or sweets shop.
Only independent local businesses are included: places in Oyster Bay, then places in a neighboring town within 10 miles of the Oyster Bay center and not across water, each marked with its town and distance and linked to its listing on that town’s Local City Network site. No chains. Listings that are held or unpublished are left out.
Hours are each business’s posted weekly schedule as saved in this guide. They can change and do not cover holidays, so confirm before you go.
Updated October 2026.
Desserts in and near Oyster Bay: answers
Where can I get dessert in and near Oyster Bay?
This guide lists 5 independent dessert spots in and near Oyster Bay: bakeries & pastry shops (4) and dessert shops & sweets (1). All 5 are in neighboring West Hempstead, Baldwin and Melville and nearby towns, within 10 miles.
Where can I find bakeries & pastry shops in and near Oyster Bay?
This guide lists 4: Sydney's Sweets, Vienna Cookie Company, Banana Bread Co and Catalina's Bake Shop.
Where can I find dessert shops & sweets in and near Oyster Bay?
This guide lists 1: Emile's Candies.
How is this list made?
A place is listed when its kind is an ice cream, gelato or frozen yogurt shop, a bakery or pastry shop, a donut shop, a boba or bubble tea shop, or a dessert or sweets shop. Hours are each business’s posted weekly schedule as saved in this guide. They can change and do not cover holidays, so confirm before you go.
Are any of these dessert shops chains?
No. Every place is an independent local business in and near Oyster Bay; national ice cream, donut and bakery chains are not listed.