Oyster Bay source photograph

Outdoors

Lakes near Oyster Bay

30 named lakes within 30 miles, nearest first, with a map and directions.

Lakes within 30 mi

30

Closest

6 mi

Massapequa Lake

Within 10 miles

4

Reservoirs

17

Worth the drive

Lake Innisfree
Lake Innisfree21.4 miPhoto: Anthony22 at English Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 3.0
Jerome Park Reservoir
Jerome Park Reservoir22.7 miPhoto: jim.henderson, CC BY-SA 3.0
Harlem Meer
Harlem Meer24.1 miPhoto: Jay Dobkin, CC BY-SA 4.0
Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis Reservoir
Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis Reservoir24.5 miPhoto: Carsten Keßler from Münster, Germany, CC BY 2.0
Patchogue Lake
Patchogue Lake24.8 miPhoto: Intelligentlove at English Wikipedia, Public domain
Croton Distributing Reservoir
Croton Distributing Reservoir25.6 miPhoto: EE.UU., Public domain

Map

Map of 30 places loads as you scroll.

All lakes, nearest first

  1. 6mi
    Massapequa Lake

    Directions ↗

  2. 9.3mi
    Hempstead Lakereservoir

    Directions ↗

  3. 9.8mi
    Beaver Lake

    Directions ↗

  4. 9.8mi
    Guggenheim Lakesreservoir

    Directions ↗

  5. 11.2mi
    Lake Success

    About ↗Directions ↗

  6. 17.6mi
    Playland Lake

    Directions ↗

  7. 18.1mi
    Meadow Lake

    Directions ↗

  8. 19.7mi
    Huguenot Lakereservoir

    Directions ↗

  9. 20.1mi
    Lake Ronkonkoma

    About ↗Directions ↗

  10. 20.1mi
    Sheldrake Lake

    About ↗Directions ↗

  11. 20.1mi
    Mamaroneck Reservoirreservoir

    Directions ↗

  12. 21.1mi
    Ridgewood Reservoirreservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  13. 21.4mi
    Lake Innisfreereservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  14. 21.8mi
    Williamsbridge Reservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  15. 22.4mi
    Hillview Reservoirreservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  16. 22.7mi
    Jerome Park Reservoirreservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  17. 23.4mi
    Fyre Lakereservoir

    Directions ↗

  18. 23.8mi
    Highbridge Reservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  19. 24mi
    Grassy Sprain Reservoirreservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  20. 24.1mi
    Harlem Meer

    About ↗Directions ↗

  21. 24.4mi
    Putnam Lakereservoir

    Directions ↗

  22. 24.5mi
    Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis Reservoirreservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  23. 24.8mi
    Patchogue Lakereservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  24. 25.1mi
    The Lake

    Directions ↗

  25. 25.6mi
    Croton Distributing Reservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  26. 25.7mi
    Prospect Lakereservoir

    Directions ↗

  27. 26.9mi
    Kensico Reservoirreservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  28. 27.4mi
    Converse Lakereservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  29. 29.1mi
    Tarrytown Reservoirreservoir

    About ↗Directions ↗

  30. 29.8mi
    Upper Lake

    Directions ↗

Straight-line distance from the center of Oyster Bay; driving and trail distances are longer.

Before you go

Swim only where it is allowed

Many reservoirs are drinking-water supplies with no swimming or body contact. Look for a designated swim beach.

Watch for algae blooms

Green, scummy or paint-like water can be a toxic blue-green algae bloom. Keep kids and dogs out and check the county advisory.

Boats, fishing and fees

Boat launches often need a day pass or inspection for invasive mussels, and anglers 16 and older usually need a state fishing license.

HikingFishingBoatingWeather by monthDay tripsBeaches near Oyster BayWaterfalls near Oyster BayScenic viewpoints near Oyster BayCaves near Oyster Bay

Questions

What is the closest lake to Oyster Bay?

Massapequa Lake, about 6 miles from the center of Oyster Bay.

How many lakes are near Oyster Bay?

30 named lakes are within 30 miles, 4 of them within 10 miles.

Are the lakes near Oyster Bay natural?

17 of the 30 are reservoirs made by dams; the rest are mapped as natural lakes. Swimming rules differ, so check each one.

Sources: Wikidata and OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL), checked 2026-11-08; photos from Wikimedia Commons under the licenses shown. Access, fees and conditions change; check before visiting.

Oyster Bay AI

Your Oyster Bay local guide
Hey there!

I'm Oyster Bay AI. Ask about neighborhood food, independent shops, local history or planning a visit.

AI recommendations may be inaccurate. Verify hours and prices. Questions are processed by Cloudflare. Privacy