Oyster Bay source photograph

Outdoors

Caves near Oyster Bay

6 named caves within 75 miles, nearest first, with a map and directions.

Caves within 75 mi

6

Closest

54.8 mi

Indian Cave

Map

Map of 6 places loads as you scroll.

All caves, nearest first

  1. 54.8mi
    Indian Cave

    Directions ↗

  2. 59.2mi
    Tory cave

    About ↗Directions ↗

  3. 64.7mi
    Rock House

    Directions ↗

  4. 65.8mi
    Crooked Swamp Cave

    Directions ↗

  5. 71.5mi
    Tory's Den

    Directions ↗

  6. 73.8mi
    Will Warren's Den

    Directions ↗

Straight-line distance from the center of Oyster Bay; driving and trail distances are longer.

Before you go

Tour with a guide

Show caves run guided tours with lighting and paths; wild caves need training, gear and often a permit.

Bring a layer

Caves stay near the area’s year-round average temperature, often in the 50s °F, even in summer.

Protect the bats

Many caves close seasonally to protect hibernating bats from white-nose syndrome. Follow closures and decontamination rules.

HikingWeather by monthDay tripsBeaches near Oyster BayWaterfalls near Oyster BayLakes near Oyster BayScenic viewpoints near Oyster Bay

Questions

What is the closest cave to Oyster Bay?

Indian Cave, about 54.8 miles from the center of Oyster Bay.

How many caves are near Oyster Bay?

6 named caves are within 75 miles.

Can you visit caves near Oyster Bay?

Some are show caves with guided tours and others sit in parks with marked trails. Check each cave’s park or operator for tour times, closures and age limits before you go.

Sources: Wikidata and OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL), checked 2026-11-08; photos from Wikimedia Commons under the licenses shown. Access, fees and conditions change; check before visiting.

Oyster Bay AI

Your Oyster Bay local guide
Hey there!

I'm Oyster Bay AI. Ask about neighborhood food, independent shops, local history or planning a visit.

AI recommendations may be inaccurate. Verify hours and prices. Questions are processed by Cloudflare. Privacy